Update: I finally tried a water based poly on a table top
I mean, everyone says oil based is the only way for a tough finish, but after using General Finishes water based poly on a maple table, the clarity and lack of smell was a game changer. It's been six months with zero yellowing. Has anyone else had a good long term result with water based on high use pieces?
Right, the "two years and still clear" part is the real kicker. That's what I'm after too. I think a lot of people just accept that plastic stuff is gonna turn gross after a while, but it doesn't have to be that way if you start with a good quality sheet. It's wild how much of a difference it makes for the whole look of a room, not just the table. Totally worth the little extra effort to find the ones that actually stay see-through.