Update: I thought trimming brisket fat to a quarter inch was overkill, a judge in Fort Worth proved me wrong | BBQ Pitmasters - Freelance Forum - The Community for Independent Professionals
Update: I thought trimming brisket fat to a quarter inch was overkill, a judge in Fort Worth proved me wrong
I used to leave closer to half an inch of fat cap on my packers because I figured it bastes the meat. Then I did a backyard contest in Fort Worth and the judge pulled me aside after turn-in and said the fat was "greasy and gray" on the slices. He told me to trim to about a quarter inch and let the bark carry it, so I tried it on the next two cooks and the slices came out cleaner with way better bark. I still get nervous scraping that much off, but the results don't lie. What trim thickness are you all running on your packers these days?
The thickness matters less than how even you get it. A quarter inch in the middle but a half inch hanging off the edge gives you that gray greasy strip on some slices and clean bark on others. I go over the whole cap with a sharp knife and feel it with my palm, not just eyeball it. Also check the fat between the flat and the point, that seam holds a lot of grease if you leave it thick.