23
Debate: should a book club read the movie adaptation before or after the original book?
My book club is split right down the middle on this. Half of us think you read the book first so you can form your own opinions without the movie coloring things. The other half says watch the movie first because it's shorter and gets everyone on the same page quicker, then the book adds depth. We tried it both ways now and I'm still not sure which works better. What do you all do in your clubs?
3 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In3 Comments
white.keith5h ago
Our club was in the exact same spot last year, so we ran a three-month experiment where we read the book first for one pick, watched the movie first for another, and did both at once for the third. Honestly, the book first approach led to way deeper discussions about the author's intent and character development, but the movie first crowd got more people to actually finish the book since they already cared about the characters from the film. What really settled it for me was when we did a complicated novel like "Gone Girl" - reading the book first let us catch all those little clues the movie had to skip, and the conversation stayed focused on the writing itself instead of just complaining about missing scenes. So yeah, team book first here, but I get why some people prefer the shortcut version.
7
sam_cooper9h ago
Honestly I'm team book first all the way. Watching the movie first just plants someone else's vision in your head before you even get a chance to picture things yourself. But here's my real question for your group - does the order change how much you guys actually talk about the book vs the movie? Like when you watched the movie first, did the discussion still focus on the book's themes or did it just turn into a argument about what the movie changed? Because that's what happened with my last club and it threw the whole vibe off.
4
4