Loading…
30
Why I'm going back to books for plant identification
I see so many people praising plant ID apps, but I think they cause more problems than they solve. Last month, I scanned a shrub in my garden and the app labeled it as invasive, so I started digging it up. Turns out it was a native species that just looked similar in the photo. Now I have a hole in my yard for no reason. These apps often get confused by leaf shape or flower color in different light. I've followed their watering advice and ended up drowning a succulent that needed dry soil. My old botany book has clear drawings and descriptions that never let me down. It might be slower, but I trust it way more. Maybe apps are fine for quick guesses, but for real plant love, they just don't cut it.
4 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In4 Comments
victor6516mo ago
Funny you should say that, because my phone app saved my garden last spring. I was about to pull up what I thought was a weed, but the app told me it was a rare wildflower. Sure, apps can mess up sometimes, but so can books if you're not careful with the pictures. The best part is getting instant info, like if a plant is toxic to pets, which my old book didn't cover. I get why you'd stick with books, but for quick checks, these apps are a game changer. Maybe it's about using both together, you know?
4
jason_knight6mo ago
Your app called that common weed rare?
1
the_olivia6mo ago
Ever have a book with a blurry photo or a description that just doesn't match what's in front of you? That's where the app helps me... it's like a second opinion. Sure, it might mess up a name sometimes, but so can I when I'm flipping pages. The instant part is what I need, because I'm trying to learn while I'm actually out there looking at the plant.
8
piperk886mo ago
What gets me is how these apps turn nature into a data game. It’s not about learning the plant anymore, it’s about scanning it to add to your digital collection or get a badge. That mindset totally changes why you’re even outside. You stop looking at the whole environment and just hunt for the next thing to point your phone at. Books make you slow down and actually compare details, which builds real knowledge. The app might tell you the name, but it doesn’t teach you how to see.
3